One film, two versions: The Quiet American

Today’s choice is a rare example of a remake that is so much better than the original, it leaves me recommending the modern version as the only one to watch. In 1958, Hollywood filmed the Graham Greene novel ‘The Quiet American’, starring Audie Murphy and Michael Redgrave. Neither stars were the first choices, or even the second, and despite some filming taking place in Vietnam (where the story is set) much of it was shot in Italy instead.

If you don’t know the story, it is set in 1952, during the revolt against French rule in the country. A young American (Murphy) has arrived to work for an aid organisation, though he may secretly be a CIA spy, checking out the country for later US involvement in the region. He meets a distinguished British journalist (Redgrave) and falls for the older man’s beautiful Vietnamese girlfriend, taking her away from his friend. As a result, the journalist exposes America’s shady dealings of supporting the anti-communists in the country, and giving them arms.

The film outraged Graham Greene by changing the political emphasis, and making it appear that America was doing the ‘right thing’. And despite a classically understated and powerful performance from the distinguished Redgrave, Audie Murphy was woefully miscast in his role.

Then in 2002, another version was made, by Philip Noyce. This starred Michael Caine and Brendan Fraser, with Caine as the journalist, and Fraser in the role played by Audie Murphy in the earlier film. By this time of course, we had seen the French defeated in Vietnam, and the long war that followed against the US and their South Vietnamese allies. Most people had some idea of the background, and the events that led up to it, shown in Greene’s novel, and the earlier film.

But crucially, the modern film stuck to Greene’s original story, and ending. The often clumsy Fraser stepped up to portray the American so well, and Michael Caine gave one of his best performances as the world-weary journalist, which earned him three nominations for Best Actor. The whole film was shot in Vietnam, with locations including Hanoi and Saigon. This was the film that should have been made in 1958, if it hadn’t been for casting errors, and the dark shadow of the McCarthy witch-hunts. If you have never seen it, I really recommend you do.

34 thoughts on “One film, two versions: The Quiet American

  1. Michael Caine is always someone (almost) never disappoints (well…let’s not talk about Jaws the Revenge πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚). But this was a great film. I haven’t seen the original, but I always trust your judgement on these matters so I will take your word on it. It was also nice to see a totally different role from Brendan Fraser (who has pretty much disappeared into thin air these days it seems).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Michel. Caine often took roles in poor films just for the money, and was unapologetic about that. Fraser was someone I didn’t care for at all, but their combination in this film worked well, as the original pairing of Murphy and Redgrave felt awkward, and unconvincing.
      Best wishes, Pete.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Mary. The original changed the emphasis from Greene’s intention to show the Americans as responsible for many of the problems following the French defeat. It focused on America ‘defeating Communism’ in the region instead. It was 1958 of course, and most Americans were worried about ‘Reds under the bed’. πŸ™‚
      Best wishes, Pete.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Yay! I love Michael Caine and Brendan Fraser in the remake. I haven’t seen the original and admire Mr. Audie, but I’ll skip it. I was thinking a bit ago about revisiting this remake so it’s nice to see you featuring it here today. Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

All comments welcome

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.